What Separates Good Writers From Bad Ones?

by John Wallis

Writing looks deceptively simple, right? We all learned it in school and we all do it daily—emails, texts, posts, messages. Yet when it comes to professional writing, creative writing, or content that actually performs, the gap between good writers and bad writers is enormous. We see it instantly. We feel it within the first paragraph.

So what truly separates good writers from bad ones?

It isn’t talent alone or education. It isn’t even vocabulary size or fancy language. The difference actually runs deeper—in habits, mindset, discipline, and execution.

Let’s break it down clearly, directly,  without the fluff.

Good Writers Think Before They Write

Bad writers start typing immediately. Good writers pause.

They ask:

• Who are we writing for?
• What problem are we solving?
• What emotion or action should this trigger?

Good writers understand that writing is not self-expression—it is communication. Every sentence exists for the reader, not the writer’s ego. Before the first word is written, good writers already know the destination.

Bad writers wander. Good writers navigate.

This clarity alone eliminates confusion, rambling, and wasted paragraphs.

Based on Shelley's best selling novel, A Legacy of Shadows chronicles what can happen when one man's quest for immortality goes awry. Based on a near-future narrartive,  A Legacy of Shadows is a must read for those who believe leaving a lasting legacy is the single most important thing in their lives. 

Bad Writers Chase Inspiration, Good Writers Build Systems

Bad writers wait to “feel like writing.” Good writers write whether they feel like it or not.

This is one of the most critical differences.

Good writers rely on process, not mood. They:

• Write on a schedule
• Set word-count targets
• Edit consistently
• Treat writing like work, not magic

Bad writers romanticize creativity. Good writers respect it enough to show up daily.

Consistency beats inspiration every time.

Good Writers Obsess Over Clarity, Not Cleverness

Bad writers try to sound smart. Good writers try to be understood.

Clarity is the invisible superpower of great writing. Good writers remove:

• Unnecessary words
• Complicated sentence structures
• Vague phrases
• Overwritten descriptions

They know that clear writing signals clear thinking.

Bad writers hide behind complexity. Good writers simplify without dumbing down. Every sentence moves forward with purpose.

Fulfill your dream of an MFA without having to devote tons of money or time. The Portable MFA  gives you all of the essential information you would learn in the MFA program in one book. Covering fiction, memoirs, personal essays, magazine articles, poetry, and playwriting, 

Bad Writers Write for Approval, Good Writers Write for Impact

Bad writers ask:

• “Will people like this?”
• “Is this impressive enough?”
• “Does this make me look smart?”

Good writers ask:

• “Does this help?”
• “Does this move the reader?”
• “Does this change how they think or act?”

Good writers understand that writing is not about validation—it’s about value delivery. They are willing to be direct, bold, and occasionally uncomfortable if it serves the message.

That courage shows up on the page.

Good Writers Read Constantly (Bad Writers Rarely Do)

Strong writing is built on strong reading habits.

Good writers read:

• Articles in their niche
• Books outside their comfort zone
• Copy, fiction, essays, and journalism
• Both good writing and bad writing

They study structure. They notice rhythm. They analyze what holds attention and what loses it.

Bad writers assume writing skill exists in isolation. Good writers know reading is unpaid training.

Creative Writing Mfa Handbook: A Guide for Prospective Graduate Students (Revised & Updated)

Bad Writers Edit Lightly, Good Writers Edit Ruthlessly

The first draft means nothing.

Good writers understand that writing is rewriting. They cut aggressively. They reshape paragraphs. They move sentences. They delete pages without regret.

They edit for:

• Flow
• Precision
• Tone
• Engagement
• Search intent (when writing online)

Bad writers fall in love with their first draft. Good writers fall in love with the final result.

Good Writers Respect the Reader’s Time

Bad writers pad content. Good writers earn attention.

Every paragraph written by a good writer justifies its existence. There is no filler. No vague setup. No wasted introduction.

They know modern readers:

• Scan before reading
• Leave quickly
• Demand value immediately

So good writers deliver substance early and often. They structure content for skimming while rewarding deep reading.

Bad Writers Avoid Feedback, Good Writers Seek It

Feedback is uncomfortable. Good writers lean into it anyway.

They:

• Share drafts
• Accept criticism
• Separate ego from work
• Use feedback to sharpen skill

Bad writers defend their writing. Good writers improve it.

Growth lives on the other side of critique.

The Courage to Write is an invaluable book and essential reading for anyone who wishes to learn how to write well.

Good Writers Master Fundamentals Before Experimenting

Bad writers want shortcuts. Good writers master the basics.

Before breaking rules, good writers dominate:

• Sentence structure
• Paragraph flow
• Grammar
• Punctuation
• Logical progression

They understand that style without structure collapses quickly. Once fundamentals are internalized, experimentation becomes intentional—not chaotic.

Bad Writers Write to Finish, Good Writers Write to Connect

Bad writers aim to “get it done.” Good writers aim to be remembered.

They care about:

• Emotional resonance
• Reader experience
• Voice consistency
• Long-term trust

Good writers understand that connection creates loyalty, and loyalty builds authority—whether in fiction, content marketing, blogging, or professional communication.

Good Writers Treat Writing as a Skill, Not an Identity

This distinction matters more than most realize.

Bad writers say, “I am a writer.” Good writers say, “I practice writing.”

Good writers accept that:

• Skill fluctuates
• Improvement is endless
• Every piece teaches something

They stay teachable. They stay curious. They stay grounded.

Even a quick glance at popular books, movies, and streaming series says it all-- a skillful application of tropes sells stories. That’s because tropes create a foundation between the audience and the action.

The Real Difference Comes Down to Discipline

At the core, the separation is simple.

Bad writers:

• Wait
• Avoid discomfort
• Chase shortcuts
• Quit early

Good writers:

• Show up
• Rewrite relentlessly
• Learn continuously
• Finish what they start

Talent helps. Discipline decides.

Final Thoughts

The line between good writers and bad ones is not fixed. It’s not genetic. It’s not exclusive.

It is built—sentence by sentence—through habits, intention, and persistence.

Anyone willing to do the work can cross that line.

And those who do? They don’t just write better. They think better, communicate better, and influence more effectively.